Giuseppe Bocchi, Founder and CEO of BRD srl, is a top-notch Italian mechanical engineer with a passion for mechanical engines (internal combustion engines). He has an incredible breadth of experience built working for prestigious companies such as Lamborghini, Ferrari, Ducati and MV Agusta, where as Chief Project and R&D Engineer he designed and brought to world dominance the four cylinder St. 76/50 and St. 76/35 racers led to World Title supremacy by Giacomo Agostini and Phil Read.
I met Giuseppe Bocchi several years ago in Parma (Italy) when he was still using the drawing board for the early stages of the design process. At that time I was working for the University of Parma and with my students we were looking for some real-world exercises. I asked Giuseppe for the design of an engine part to optimize its shape with the use of software tools. He gave us a 2D handmade technical drawing of a new engine he never had the time to complete. We went back to the lab. The students created a full 3D CAD model of the selected piece. We noticed an unusual group of ribs across the part. At first glance, they looked excessively sized to us, and we asked Giuseppe the reason. His simple answer was: "At this stage of the design process I don't have any data, but the part looks beautiful with those ribs." We went back to the lab and the students ran several tests with a sophisticated FEM/FEA tool trying several 3D models with differently sized ribs. All the results pointed in the same direction: the best possible ribs were the ones chosen by Giuseppe. That day I learned that the greatest designers need FEM/FEA tools only to produce the final technical reports; they intuitively recognize the optimal shape simply as the most beautiful. Giuseppe Bocchi is one of these exceptional designers.
Giuseppe, can you tell us a bit about yourself and your professional activities?
I started working for very famous and world renowned companies such as Lamborghini, Ferrari, MV Agusta, and Ducati
I’m the President of BRD, a company active in the field of highly advanced design of hi-tech internal combustion engines. Our primary activity is the development of “turn key” projects (from basic calculations to CAD-CAM & CAE production blueprints) of highly advanced internal combustion engines.
After graduating from the University of Bologna, I started working for very famous and world renowned companies such as Lamborghini Automobili, Ferrari Automobili, Pederzani Automobili Racing Team, and MV Agusta, Ducati.
In 1980 I started my own design and research center: BRD. I still lead in my company as both President and CEO and as highly inspired scientific and technical leader of the design and engineering teams. Through the past 24 years of its activity, BRD has been offered the opportunity to cooperate with some of today’s leading automotive and motorcycling companies. For these clients we have developed projects of engines for both racing and street use. In addition to that, we have been very successfully operating in aerospace engineering, and specifically in the development of kerosene fueled turbo-diesel engines for light and medium aircrafts and drones.
The advanced activity specifically concerning modeling, simulation, and experimental validation of acoustics and thermo-fluidodynamic phenomena in internal combustion engine is fully executed in house thanks to dedicated softwares developed and patented by BRD. BRD also supports a full loop R&D and design activity with its capability of developing, manufacturing and fully testing the related prototypes within its state of the art facilities.
I'm also the author of a book “Motori a quattro tempi” (Four Stroke Engines), sold in many thousands copies, published by Hoepli, the most important scientific publishers in Italy.
You started designing long before the appearance of CAD systems for the PC. Which CAD systems are you currently using and how are you using them?
We currently use Pro/Engineer, Unigraphics, SolidWorks, and AutoCAD. In my experience Pro/Engineer and Unigraphics are the best tools for designing engines. Pro/Engineer is more specific for mechanical engineering of internal combustion engine, but it’s more rigid than the others. It’s widely used in Europe. I believe a very popular CAD system in US is the very powerful and completeUnigraphics. It has several modules and it supports the design of the whole vehicle. Also CATIA has this capability, but it’s more used in the aerospace industry. I consider SolidWorks the easiest, but I found it limited in the management of assemblies and complex surfaces.
As a consultant you have been working with manufacturing companies all over the world. How have your clients’ requests changed over the years?
the tendency today is to have a complete and ready project including the prototype
The complex mechanism of business changes day by day. The tendency today is to have a complete and ready project including the prototype. Some years ago our activity was mainly consultancy and engine design. Today customers, especially those of Europe, want a running prototype and they put in the contracts requests for warranties and penalties.
It is important to assemble and test the prototypes in our facilities, because as the designers of the engine and we know very well the characteristics of the product. So we can easily find the best tuning.
For this reason, we have a workshop and a test bench locatednear the technical office.
You are very active with emerging manufacturing companies from China. So far how has your experience been working with them?
now BRD is well known all over the world
It started more or less two years ago. The contact happened quickly and spontaneously. Usually Chinese manufacturers send scouters to Europe to study the European companies. Then the chairman comes to visit the chosen ones and at the end they draw up the contract. Chinese people don’t want to be contacted, they prefer to start the contact themselves. In fact, three years ago, we tried to approach some Asian companies with an Internet advertisements campaign, but with no result. Now BRD is well known all over the world.
Chinese people are very detail-oriented, unlike Italians, and with them it is difficult to reach agreements in a short time. They can work without breaks for many hours. They have a different concept of work. Initially communication is difficult; after a while it becomes much easier.
You have a long history of designing internal combustion engines. What are the strengths and the limitations of CAD systems in supporting these designing activities?
we have to buy several CAD systems to satisfy different customers' requests
Of course CAD technology allows designers to save time and money. During the design process, a designer with a CAD system can make a modification easily and quickly. With the old drawing board we had just two dimensions: thanks to CAD today we can work with three dimensions and so immediately have the a full perception of the model. Moreover, during the design process, CAD also allows for the control of the movements of all parts of the engine design: the dimensions, the drafts, the tools paths and the layout in general. It simplifies the designing of the production cycle, from the casting to the final tooling. Usually an interface is available between the CAD system and rapid prototyping and rapid tooling, so the prototyping and production times are short. Another very important capability is the integration between CAD and CAE systems. It’s possible to make simulations to optimize the shape and the structure of some critical parts. For example, through fluidodynamic simulation it is possible to optimize the shape and the geometry of manifold and mufflers; with aerodynamic simulation it’s easier to design a correct shape for the bodies. So the modifications can be made without the construction of the real parts.
In spite of that, we have to buy several kinds of CAD systems, because we have to satisfy different customers' requests: everyone use a particular CAD. To create an efficient designing department is expensive because it’s necessary to buy several licenses (one for each working station), to pay the training courses, and to stay updated with the last release of the software. And this kind of software needs an adequate hardware infrastructure.
On top of that, there are some bugs in the CAD code, so sometimes it can be difficult working with imported geometries.
I know you have been working on what might be revolutionary engine for some time. Can you tell us more about it?
this type of engine (cam engine) is very advantageous from the point of view of the thermodynamic efficiency
I think you are talking about “cam engine” (2 cylinders, 4 cylinders). This type of engine is very advantageous from the point of view of the thermodynamic efficiency. It takes advantage of the exploitation of the burnt gas energy, utilizing appropriate piston motion laws, different from the classical mechanism of the con-rod and crank.
Cam engines are very light, they have little axial dimension, and they are made of few components. For all these reasons and because of their low specific consumption, they are very suitable to the aeronautical applications.
I hope that in a near future this kind of engine will reach the production stage and attract some real customers.
The problem is to find the economical means to carry out the durability tests, to tune the engines under the pollution limits, and to start production.
Italy has an incredible tradition of designing the most powerful and beautiful cars (Ferrari, Lamborghini, Maserati, etc.) and motorbikes (Ducati, Guzzi, Cagiva, Aprilia, etc.). What is the status of the Italian mechanical industry?
fantasy and genius have always been characteristics of Italians
Fantasy and genius have always been characteristics of Italians. I think our realizations will always be unique, especially for high level products such as the ones you mentioned. Italian companies will always survive because their products are not repeatable and undergo continuous improvement. On the other hand, products at lower levels will be easy imitated and companies in this area will be overtaken from Asian markets because of their lower prices.
I foresee, in a near future, a very hard competition in this last field, made even harder as a consequence of the Italians' high production costs. This will be the most important problem for our politicians to resolve.
I would like to thank Giuseppe Bocchi for taking the time to answer my questions. If you have any questions for Giuseppe or for Novedge, please leave a comment below and we will be glad to answer.
Update: I forgot to mention that in 1994 I wrote a scientific paper in collaboration with Giuseppe Bocchi. The article was presented at the 27th International Symposium on Automotive Technology and Automation in Aachen, Germany and published for the ISATA proceedings. The title of the article is: Rapid Prototyping and Parametric CAD Systems.
Comments will be approved before showing up.