Is Google Fair?

May 01, 2007 2 min read

Let’s start with the facts.

A few days ago I was working at the data feed for a Google service called Google Base, previously known as Froogle. It’s an online service that allows sellers to upload a list of products with price and description and lets users search online for products to compare prices, shipping fees, and seller ratings.

for Google Base, PayPal is not a syntactically valid option

The new Google Base accepts a feed in a few different formats. One of the most flexible formats available is RSS 2.0, a popular XML format. The accepted payment type is among the optional information sellers can provide for each product. The following is a snippet of the XML code I submitted to Google. I’m confident that you don’t need to be an XML guru to understand this code:

<g:payment_accepted>
    MasterCard
</g:payment_accepted>

<g:payment_accepted>
    Visa
</g:payment_accepted>

<g:payment_accepted>
    PayPal
</g:payment_accepted>

A few hours after the upload I received a notification that the syntax of my XML feed was not valid. Here is the error message I got:

cvc-enumeration-valid: 
Value 'PayPal' is not facet-valid
with respect to enumeration
'[Cash, Check, Cheque, Visa, MasterCard,
Discover, AmericanExpress,
WireTransfer, GoogleCheckout]'.
It must be a value from the enumeration.

Translation in plain English: You specify that your online store accepts payment by Visa, MasterCard, and PayPal. For Google Base, PayPal is not a syntactically valid option, while GoogleCheckout is.

Is this just an oversight? Should we blame the omittance of PayPal on a Google programmer who perhaps forgot to include PayPal (Google Checkout's competition) in the list of payment options?

Or is this a poor implementation of the Google motto “Don’t be evil”?

Franco Folini

P.S.: According to this online Google Base Schema (line 419) PayPal is a syntactically valid option for payment, while Google Checkout is not even listed.  I guess this is not the Schema used to validate my feed. I would not recommend to check the XML schema if you are not familiar with XML.

Franco Folini
Franco Folini


Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Also in NOVEDGE Blog

The Art of Mastering V-Ray for SketchUp with a Powerful New Guide
The Art of Mastering V-Ray for SketchUp with a Powerful New Guide

July 09, 2020 3 min read

Learn how to create stunning 3D artwork by gaining knowledge with the most powerful rendering engine out there.
Read More
CYPE, Technical Software for Architecture, Engineering and Construction Hits the American Market-NOVEDGE
CYPE, Technical Software for Architecture, Engineering and Construction Hits the American Market

June 24, 2020 2 min read

CYPE occupies a leading position within the AEC sector, offering a variety of programs that stand out. CYPE is hitting the US market and we couldn't be more excited.
Read More
View and Exchange 3D Data in a Multi-CAD world with CAD Exchanger-NOVEDGE
View and Exchange 3D Data in a Multi-CAD world with CAD Exchanger

June 12, 2020 5 min read

CAD Exchanger helps Engineers (including Product Designers and Software Developers) understanding each other in a multi-CAD world.
Read More

Subscribe